Comic Book Plus Forum

Comic And Book Related => Comic Talk => Topic started by: Roygbiv666 on October 03, 2010, 02:32:13 AM

Title: Alternate JSA
Post by: Roygbiv666 on October 03, 2010, 02:32:13 AM
Check out this famous cover of the first appearance of the Justice Society of America, the first super-team in comics.

http://dc.wikia.com/wiki/File:All-Star_Comics_3.jpg

Who would you put in each seat for different companies? They don't have to be power parallels, just who you like.

For example, if Standard/Better/Great/Nedor/whatever had done one, they might have had, left to right:

American Crusader
Black Terror
Captain Future
Doc Strante
Fighting Yank
Grim Reaper
Miss Masque
Pyroman

What about Centaur, etc.

I was thinking of getting a comic art commission, and this famous cover would be cool to replicate.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 03, 2010, 02:38:51 AM
I'dlike to see The Shield, Steel Sterling, Mr. Justice, Amazing Man, The Comet, Plastic Man, Doll Man, Major Victory, and The Green Mask. Just some of my favorites.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: boox909 on October 03, 2010, 03:01:13 AM
I'd want to see The Black Spider (Ace), Duke of Darkness (Croydon), Iron Skull (Centaur), Black Cat (Harvey), The Phantom Reporter (Timely), The Owl (Dell), and The Hood (Harvey) for starters.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 03, 2010, 03:05:21 AM
Good choices. There should be a woman among them but the only one that pops into my mind right now is Pat Parker war nurse but I don't know if she counts. Did she have super powers?
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: boox909 on October 03, 2010, 03:07:26 AM

Good choices. There should be a woman among them but the only one that pops into my mind right now is Pat Parker war nurse but I don't know if she counts. Did she have super powers?



War Nurse is a good choice...no powers I think, but that did not stop Black Canary, Black Cat, Woman in Red.  ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 03, 2010, 03:16:02 AM
True enough. I like the Black Hood and he had no powers. Come to think of it my mother-in-law has no super powers per se' but has the ability to make me mute and unable to form an opinion.  ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 03, 2010, 04:09:12 AM
Black Dwarf = Atom
Enchanted Dagger=Sandman
Mister 'E' = Specter
Firebrand=Flash
Rocketman=Hawkman
Lady Satan=Doctor Fate
Master Key=Green Lantern
Black Cobra=Hourman

Seven Soldiers of Victory
Green Arrow = Green Knight
Speedy=Johnny Rebel
Vigilante = Black Satan
Shining Knight=Dynamic Man
Star Spangled Kid=Yankee Boy
Stripsey=Echo

Crimson Avenger = Scarlet Sentry
Star Spangled Kid=




Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: boox909 on October 03, 2010, 04:15:53 AM


Star Spangled Kid= Wonder Boy



Wonder Boy perhaps?  ???
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on October 03, 2010, 12:39:02 PM
No particular direct swaps:-
Miss Victory;
The Hood;
Black Terror ( for a bit of pure, unsubtle power);
The Ray;
Magno (and Davey);
The Web;
Blue Beetle.

And to be different, A non N. American suggestion:-
Asso di Picche ( Ace of Spades - the Hugo Pratt Masked man);
Ace Hart ( flight, strength, Ray gun, atomic energy);
Mister X (John Smith, the Italian superhero with the atomic ray in his belt and the 2nd. Italian hero after Asso di Picche, I think);
Mr. X The British masked hero from The Dandy, 1944 - Len Manners, private eye;
El Encapuchado ( Spanish hero from pulps and comics and a great way to shoehorn in a hood just like that worn by The Hood);
Electro Girl (British heroine from the'40's with, strangely enough, electrical powers);
Captain Atom ( the Australian Hero whose title outsold Superman in Oz. for a while)

This is great fun.  Already making a further alternative list.  Keep them coming.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 03, 2010, 12:54:09 PM
That's a great selection. I'd love to see an international stew of heroes and heroines. Just imagine them trying to make a meal;
"You eat sausage made of blood?"
"What? Vegemite? Gross?"
"Meatloaf? Yuck!"
"Soup? Cold? Bleck!"
"Hot Dog? What ISN"T in it?"
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 03, 2010, 04:12:59 PM
Star Spangled Kid was already listed above as Yankee Boy it just got retyped. Too easy just to name any old hero you like. Come on give it some thought. Direct swaps from one publisher or perhaps a couple of smaller publishers.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: boox909 on October 03, 2010, 04:31:45 PM

Star Spangled Kid was already listed above as Yankee Boy it just got retyped. Too easy just to name any old hero you like. Come on give it some thought. Direct swaps from one publisher or perhaps a couple of smaller publishers.



OY! Too much thinking!!!  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on October 03, 2010, 05:30:51 PM
OOOOOH-errrr!  These aren't just any old heroes.  You insult their honour.  I'll be sending round the Association of Alternate Anglophile Also Rans to have a word with you - and you wont like it.
This makes things difficult for me as I don't have a wide enough knowledge of which obscure America heroes are from which co.  I'll give it another go.  As for the Non USA list - no excuses.  Get your deerstalkers on and look them up.  I've got to do that with your lot.  Bye now.  I'm off for dinner.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 03, 2010, 10:32:32 PM
Not meant to discourage your choice of heroes at all Paw. Just would like to see direct swaps. Definetly do not have to be American. Picking a European cast would be cool. What would be better is if you could include a picture and powers since most of us Anglos would not know them.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: beowulf on October 04, 2010, 12:43:30 AM
Well, I thought up an All Centaur JLA as opposed to JSA:

Superman= Amazing Man
Batman= Fantom of the Fair
Wonder Woman= Super Ann Star
Flash= Dash Dartwell, the Human Meteor
Green Lantern= Craig Carter and his Magic Ring
Hawkman= Air Man
Green Arrow= THE Arrow
Black Canarey= Blue Lady
Martian Manhunter= Magician from Mars (some time travel and gender bending involved)
The Atom= Minimidget (and Ritty, of course).
Aqua Man= The Shark
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 04, 2010, 01:10:55 AM
Another good selection!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 04, 2010, 01:48:02 AM
This group tends to gravitate towards Centaur  :D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Astaldo711 on October 04, 2010, 02:03:42 AM
I've noticed that most people are Centaur fanatics. I'm an MLJ fan. I'm full of PEP but I do like some of the Centaur characters - Amanzing Man of course, and Fantoman.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: beowulf on October 04, 2010, 05:03:15 AM
And who doesn't like The Eye, who's like, a big flaming eye. And stuff.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Roygbiv666 on October 04, 2010, 12:30:35 PM

And who doesn't like The Eye, who's like, a big flaming eye. And stuff.


Now imagine him(?) "sitting" at the table. Ha!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on October 04, 2010, 01:36:30 PM
I have a couple of non USA lists ready.  That bit is no problem and I'm also working on a British version of Teen Titans. (Since beowulf put up a JLA alternative). Problem is that my illos for the characters are on Photobucket and I've forgotten what to do to get a "clickable thumbnail"? on to GAC.  It's so complicated and if I press the wrong button I'm going to feel like a right dunderheid.  Can anyone help.  I'll even accept a bit of condescension.
Aidez-moi, mon Robert.
(That's Maw Broon talking French)
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: beowulf on October 04, 2010, 03:59:51 PM
(Innocent Human): "What the %*#@ are you?"

(The Eye): I Am The Eye! I See All!"

"Wow. Okay. But if you're just a big flaming eye, then how can you talk with no mouth?

"Er. . Uh. . I Mean. . . ." (Flies off into the night) "Flaming Eye!"
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Roygbiv666 on October 20, 2010, 01:43:16 AM

(Innocent Human): "What the %*#@ are you?"

(The Eye): I Am The Eye! I See All!"

"Wow. Okay. But if you're just a big flaming eye, then how can you talk with no mouth?

"Er. . Uh. . I Mean. . . ." (Flies off into the night) "Flaming Eye!"


Pointy sticks are his kryptonite.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: scuttle on October 20, 2010, 11:20:31 PM


(Innocent Human): "What the %*#@ are you?"

(The Eye): I Am The Eye! I See All!"

"Wow. Okay. But if you're just a big flaming eye, then how can you talk with no mouth?

"Er. . Uh. . I Mean. . . ." (Flies off into the night) "Flaming Eye!"


Pointy sticks are his kryptonite.


And eye wash is his spinach.

Also: has anyone seen "12 Ounce Mouse"? Because this guy is there!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 02, 2013, 06:40:57 PM
I Have an idea:let's post alternate JSAs comprised of retro golden age superheroes!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 02, 2013, 07:44:00 PM
Look at the first page of this thread to see some examples of this.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 02, 2013, 09:31:30 PM
I Did already,You guys came up with some great ideas.
Keep up the good work.
Here is my alternate JSA Roster:
Diamond Jack=Green Lantern
Pat Patriot=Wonder Woman
Mister Justice=Spectre
Raven(Ace)=Sandman
Eagle=Hawkman
Quicksilver(Quality)=Flash
Nightro=Doctor Mid-nite
The Clock=Hourman
Blue Beetle(Fox)=Atom
Black Fury(Fox)=Batman
Wonderman(Fox)=Superman
Cat-Man(holyoke)=Wildcat
Daredevil=Mister Terrific
The Comet=Starman
The Green Lama=Doctor Fate
Black Cat=Black Canary
Just"N"Right=Johnny Thunder
Please tell me what you think of this!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 03, 2013, 03:34:58 AM
Pretty good match up there fate
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 03, 2013, 06:32:09 PM
Ready for another?  Good!

The Lightning (Milson) Comics meta-team would of necessity be slightly smaller than the JSA, but still quite worthy of their places at the round table:

Fatman
Tinman
Anti-Man (remember, he intended to join the good guys even though that never quite happened)
Grollo (who did join the good guys)
Sugar Kane (politically incorrect Secretary a la Wonder Woman; let's assume she had gained powers of an unknown nature too, offstage)
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 03, 2013, 10:41:45 PM
The Milson team has to include their other title character Super Green Beret. And if we add the other "two title" publisher, MF Enterprises we can come up with an interesting team including Captain Marvel which I guess we can call XAM then the repentant Tinyman and Atom-Jaw

Maybe if some of the other villains converted more of the JSA could be filled out. Not a lot of easy matches.

Elasticman
The Bat (The Ray)
Mr Brilliant
Vapor Man
Doctor Darkness
Colonel Cold
The Destroyer
Big Max
Professor Doom
Dr Fate
FATMAN villians
Gung Ho
Bug

Super Green Beret=Green Lantern
Grollo=Hourman
Tinyman=Atom
Tinman=Batman
Fatman=Superman
Xam=Starman
Anti Man=Doctor Fate
Sugar Kane=Black Canary

Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 04, 2013, 01:48:39 AM

The Milson team has to include their other title character Super Green Beret. And if we add the other "two title" publisher, MF Enterprises we can come up with an interesting team including Captain Marvel which I guess we can call XAM then the repentant Tinyman and Atom Jaw.

Super Green Beret=Green Lantern
Grollo=Hourman
Tinyman=Atom
Tinman=Batman
Fatman=Superman
Xam=Starman
Anti-Man=Doctor Fate
Sugar Kane=Black Canary


A few comments...

OK, I could live with Super Green Beret tossed into the mix, but not his original name and the historical quagmire that'd come along with it.  Re-dub him "Super Guardsman" for our times, perhaps ...?

I also could live with bringing the "Earth MF" heroes on board (their own rogues' gallery, not so much), once one not-insurmountable quibble was resolved:

(1) "Xam", in the name of non-awkward English, would need to be understood as being pronounced either "Zham" or "Jham" (just my opinion, but "Ex-am" would never fly, or split).  So ... what about a reasonable name adjustment to "Captain Xam"?

So:

Super Guardsman = Green Lantern
Grollo = Hourman
Tinyman = Atom
Tinman = Batman
Fatman = Superman
Captain Xam = Starman
Anti-Man = Doctor Fate
Sugar Kane = Black Canary
Atom Jaw = Red Tornado

(Cripes, I can hardly recall the last time I got the opportunity to write this much about comics, either!)
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 04, 2013, 02:45:11 AM
We can always use more comic talk.

Atom Jaw=Red Tornado or Wildcat
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 04, 2013, 02:50:52 AM
I Agree,100%
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 04, 2013, 03:14:15 AM

We can always use more comic talk.

Atom Jaw=Red Tornado or Wildcat


OK, that cements my Milson/MF team (edited above accordingly), with Red Tornado as the Atom Jaw match.  Thanks!   ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 04, 2013, 07:54:21 PM
From the pages of All Star Comics 41 comes the Milson Fass Silver League to solve the Case of the Patriotic Crimes. Fatman leads his team into battle ready to become The Human Flying Saucer when needed. When Super Guardsman touches his magic beret with a salute then evil better beware. Clad in his armor, the Tinman is no longer a 98 pound weakling. Atom Jaw is prepared to take his bite out of crime after having reformed along with Anti-man who now fights on the side of humanity. No man can resist the sickeningly deafening candy cry of Sugar Cane. Tinyman comes in to battle with his alien robot friend and ally Captain Xam.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 04, 2013, 08:24:39 PM

From the pages of All Star Comics 41 comes the Milson Fass Silver League to solve the Case of the Patriotic Crimes. Fatman leads his team into battle ready to become The Human Flying Saucer when needed. When Super Guardsman touches his magic beret with a salute then evil better beware. Clad in his armor, the Tinman is no longer a 98 pound weakling. Atom Jaw is prepared to take his bite out of crime after having reformed along with Anti-man who now fights on the side of humanity. No man can resist the sickeningly deafening candy cry of Sugar Cane. Tinyman comes in to battle with his alien robot friend and ally Captain Xam.


Holy Fudd, that's good!  (What else need be said?)   ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 04, 2013, 08:35:39 PM
And then there's ... Charlton (hoo boy)!

Naturally, the roster of the Derby Defenders would have to start with Charlton's two heaviest hitters available to us under the CB+ rules, one that migrated from Fox and the other (however briefly) from Fawcett:

Blue Beetle (the vitamin-gulping police officer, natch)
Ibis the Invincible (the launcher of Danger and Adventure)

From there, we continue down the line:

Yellowjacket
Mercury Man
Mr. Muscles
Zaza the Mystic
Nature Boy

And that's strictly from memory, mind you.  Taking as a given that I missed at least a few others, feel free to add them on!  (Then we can get to the fun of matching 'em all up.)

Prohibited, naturally, are all of Charlton's "Action Heroes" of the '60s (boo! hiss!), and probably the following as well, even if some of the books they appear in are included in the CB+ reading/downloading archives:  Sarge Steel, The Spookman, The Shape, and Atomic Mouse (kidding!!!!).

So, the floor's open for this round ...!   ;D

Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 05, 2013, 01:26:04 AM
The Charlton Premeir heroes would be OK. Technically the Action Heroes are also fine but trademarked but we can leave them out or maybe do one of just them some time.

Ibis=Doctor Fate
Blue Beetle=Hourman
Yellowjacket=Wildcat
Mercury Man=Hawkman
Mr. Muscles=Mr Terrefic
Zaza the Mystic=Jonnie Thunder
Nature Boy=Specter
Diana the Huntress=Green Arrow
Spookman with his Moonstone=Starman
Shape=Batman
Superguy=Superman
Captain USA=Flash
Green Spider=Green Lantern
Doctor Graves=Zatanna
Nyoka=Black Canary
Hercules=Wonder Woman
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 05, 2013, 01:47:46 AM
Wow,That is quite a roster,
Keep up the good work!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 05, 2013, 06:12:29 AM
Here they are from All-Star 15 the Chartlon Society of Derby. Dr. Graves assesses the situation form the astral plane. How can our heroes rescue Nature Boy? Diana the Huntress is in action with her bow while the Blue Beetle is flying in as is Mercury Man and Ibis. Yellowjacket and Mr. Muscle await a chance to help. Will Hercules arrive in time to possibly save the day? All recorded by Zaza the Mystic.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 05, 2013, 06:24:04 AM
Now we need some fan fiction writers. I would love to read some stories of the Charlton Society of Derby and Milson Fass Silver League.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 05, 2013, 01:26:39 PM

Now we need some fan fiction writers. I would love to read some stories of the Charlton Society of Derby and Milson Fass Silver League.

Yeah,right on,count me in.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on January 05, 2013, 05:58:05 PM
Mystery Men of Albion.
(A non-American society for justice.)
Ace Hart = Superman.   https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=22760
Acromaid = Black Canary.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=22601
Thunderbolt Jaxon = (not sure, so Supes, GL, but no Martian Manhunter in JSA)
https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=22761
Phantom Raider = Dr. Midnite.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=23239  (p.90)
The Falcon = Mr. Terrific.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=27539
Phantom Maid = Wonder Woman.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=23064  (p.7)
Harris Tweed = original Red Tornado.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=28480
Night Hawk = Hawkman.  http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/n/nitehawk.htm  (Night Hawk is on CB=, in an ad. in a storypaper but I can't just find it right now)
The Tornado = GL.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=26117

Best I can do 'cos there's a GORDON for dinner to look forward to in a wee while.  But there could be room for a Junior MM of Albion  if i can just get the finger out and concentrate on finding the characters.  Versions of Little Boy Blue and the Blue Boys?  And how to find the Phantom Protector.

Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 05, 2013, 06:21:59 PM
Cool Paw and Cat-Man could be added as Batman
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on January 05, 2013, 06:27:34 PM
Except he's Australian.  I tried to keep it to British heroes.  We could easily have an Aussie team.  Thinking caps on.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 05, 2013, 07:44:57 PM
Captain Atom=Superman
Cat-Man=Batman
Cometman=Starman
Blue Ghost=Dr Midnight

That is all that I could find in Australian PD. I am sure there are more.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: paw broon on January 05, 2013, 08:48:01 PM
On my tablet so cannot put in links yet. So, Jetman = ?  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=29497
Shadow =  Dr. Midnite?  OOps, where's he gone?
Grey Domino = Mr. Terrific.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=22898
Sir Falcon= Shining Knight (if we take some liberties).  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=23354
Char Chapman = Wildcat.  https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=29663
Phantom Knight = Captain Comet (liberties, again). https://comicbookplus.com/?dlid=27583

My head's starting to hurt. I'll find the links later.

The idea of a junior British version is intriguing so I have to find Captain Atlas and some others.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 05, 2013, 11:20:41 PM

Wow,That is quite a roster,
Keep up the good work!


And I'll second that, narfstar!!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 06, 2013, 02:26:08 AM

The Charlton Premeir heroes would be OK. Technically the Action Heroes are also fine but trademarked but we can leave them out or maybe do one of just them some time.


Since you put it that way, I don't suppose any of the legal eagles would particularly care if Son of Vulcan
( = Shining Knight) was tossed into the mix too.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 06, 2013, 02:03:08 PM

Captain Atom=Superman
Cat-Man=Batman
Cometman=Starman
Blue Ghost=Dr Midnight

That is all that I could find in Australian PD. I am sure there are more.

Wow,That is so cool.Keep it up.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 06, 2013, 03:58:27 PM
(http://i1082.photobucket.com/albums/j380/dad75/coverrecreation001.jpg)
Hi,Guys,
Here is a recreation i did of the cover of all-star comics#3,featuring the following characters:
the blue beetle
the raven
mister justice
quicksilver
the eagle
the green lama
diamond jack
the clock
I Left their names off the cover recreation to avoid legal problems with kendra crossen burroughs,DC Comics,
marvel comics,archie comics,AC Comics,image comics,and dynamite entertainment!
Let me know what you think.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 06, 2013, 06:49:04 PM
Thanks again, narfstar!  (To quote Bugs Bunny's nemesis, Rocky:  "I don't know how yez dunnit but I know yez DUNNIT!")   ;)

I'd just add a couple of minor tweaks to the Charlton Society of Derby:  In with Son of Vulcan (as mentioned elsewhere); out with Superguy, Captain USA, and the Green Spider (all just over the line into Super-Silly).  (Yeah, I know ... so's the Shape ... but at least there's somewhere farther off to go with him, characterization-wise.)

Ibis = Doctor Fate
Blue Beetle = Hourman
Yellowjacket = Wildcat
Mercury Man = Hawkman
Mr. Muscles = Mr. Terrific
Zaza the Mystic = Johnny Thunder
Nature Boy = Spectre
Diana the Huntress = Green Arrow
Spookman = Starman
Shape = Batman
Doctor Graves = Zatanna
Nyoka = Black Canary
Hercules = Wonder Woman
Son of Vulcan = Shining Knight
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 06, 2013, 07:25:14 PM
Pretty cool Fate.

Well if you kick out Superguy and Captain USA then Green Spider has got to go also. Which is OK. Of course we could do a comedy superhero JSA. Man something else to think about  ;D Have you seen the character Upan Atom?
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 06, 2013, 07:39:26 PM

Well if you kick out Superguy and Captain USA then Green Spider has got to go also. Which is OK. Of course we could do a comedy superhero JSA. Man something else to think about  ;D Have you seen the character Upan Atom?


OK, point taken and done deal with Green Spider (as above).  Of course, since we **are** thinking alternate DC team here, the Charlton Society of Derby **would** eventually have to meet the team of "Atom"-powered funny animals on a parallel Earth, a la Captain Carrot & company.   8)

Sorry, never heard of Upan Atom ... do tell.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: boox909 on January 06, 2013, 09:51:24 PM
I love this thread!!!  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 08, 2013, 12:26:52 AM
I have had fun with this one
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 08, 2013, 12:34:44 AM

I have had fun with this one


Ditto!  ;D
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on January 09, 2013, 03:21:52 AM
Sure Shining Knight=Son of Vulcan is fine. Maybe we need to do a Marvel match up next.
One offs GA heroes

Air Male=Red Raven
Hydroman=Subby
Combat Kid=Bucky
Mad Hatter=Whizzer (who else would pick the name Whizzer but a Mad man)
Red Rogue=Destroyer
Captain Combat=Patriot
Black Cobra=Blue Diamond
Thin Man=Echo
Thunderbolt = Original Human Torch
Captain Flash=Whizzer
Wonderboy=Marvel Boy
Sparkman=Jubalee
Captain Triumph=Wonderman
Black Cobra=The Witness
The Flame=Human Torch
Fantasmo=Hulk
Strongman=Doc Samson
Luckyman=Gambit
Purple Claw=Mister E
Willo O The Wisp=Scarlet Witch
Hyper the Phenomenal=Wonderman
Hypnox=Professor X
"Buz" Balmer=Ant Man
Lady Fairplay=Miss America
Ghost Woman=Black Widow GA
Comandette=Black Widow SA
Air Male=Red Raven
The Menace=Phantom Reporter
Congo Raider=Black Panther
Pioneer=Captain America
Invisible Avenger=Invisible Girl
Graves Ghost Hunter=Doctor Druid
Green Giant=Giant Man
Master Mystic=Doctor Strange
Tornado Tom=Quicksilver
Volton the Human Generator=Fiery Mask
Robo=Vision
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 09, 2013, 03:27:50 AM

Sure Shining Knight=Son of Vulcan is fine. Maybe we need to do a Marvel match up next.
One offs GA heroes

Air Male=Red Raven
Hydroman=Subby
Combat Kid=Bucky
Mad Hatter=Whizzer (who else would pick the name Whizzer but a Mad man)
Red Rogue=Destroyer
Captain Combat=Patriot
Black Cobra=Blue Diamond
Thin Man=Echo
Thunderbolt = Original Human Torch
Captain Flash=Whizzer
Wonderboy=Marvel Boy
Sparkman=Jubalee
Captain Triumph=Wonderman
Black Cobra=The Witness
The Flame=Human Torch
Fantasmo=Hulk
Strongman=Doc Samson
Luckyman=Gambit
Purple Claw=Mister E
Willo O The Wisp=Scarlet Witch
Hyper the Phenomenal=Wonderman
Hypnox=Professor X
"Buz" Balmer=Ant Man
Lady Fairplay=Miss America
Ghost Woman=Black Widow GA
Comandette=Black Widow SA
Air Male=Red Raven
The Menace=Phantom Reporter
Congo Raider=Black Panther
Pioneer=Captain America
Invisible Avenger=Invisible Girl
Graves Ghost Hunter=Doctor Druid
Green Giant=Giant Man
Master Mystic=Doctor Strange
Tornado Tom=Quicksilver
Volton the Human Generator=Fiery Mask
Robo=Vision

Sounds like a plan,Go for it.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: Burt Stein on January 10, 2013, 04:25:54 PM
[EDIT:  Just a little something to run with, so that more than just a few folks here have fun with this thread!]  Oddly, the equivalent Fawcett team would likely be the easiest to establish, since that company had at least three existing smaller teams from which to cherry pick, mix and match per the needs of each story:  the Marvel Family, the three Lieutenants Marvel, and the Crime Crusaders Club.  Add in Spy Smasher, Radar the International Policeman, and any lesser lights from the earlier Fawcett roster, and there you go!
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on January 10, 2013, 10:38:14 PM

[EDIT:  Just a little something to run with, so that more than just a few folks here have fun with this thread!]  Oddly, the equivalent Fawcett team would likely be the easiest to establish, since that company had at least three existing smaller teams from which to cherry pick, mix and match per the needs of each story:  the Marvel Family, the three Lieutenants Marvel, and the Crime Crusaders Club.  Add in Spy Smasher, Radar the International Policeman, and any lesser lights from the earlier Fawcett roster, and there you go!

Yeah,right on,man.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: OzMan on October 05, 2013, 09:03:26 PM

Captain Atom=Superman
Cat-Man=Batman
Cometman=Starman
Blue Ghost=Dr Midnight

That is all that I could find in Australian PD. I am sure there are more.


HEY NARFSTAR... I have a few new Aussies to add to the list!
  The Eagle = Hawkman
  Masked Archer = Green Arrow
  The Panther = Wild Cat?
  Silver Starr = Adam Strange
  Vampire = Black Canary (or Batgirl)

That's all I can think of.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 06, 2013, 03:42:22 AM
Nice and it would be great if you attached some jpg pics as I am not real familiar with the characters
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: OzMan on October 07, 2013, 02:53:28 AM

Nice and it would be great if you attached some jpg pics as I am not real familiar with the characters

@ NARFSTAR
I don't know how to post gpg pictures, but if you use this link, it will show you these Aussie heroes that I mentioned!

http://www.internationalhero.co.uk/a/ausgold.htm
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on October 07, 2013, 10:26:58 AM
Thanks Oz I was aware of the site but had forgotten it. It is easy to attach a picture. Just click on
Attachments and other options at the bottom of the reply pane.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on June 07, 2015, 07:31:20 PM

Thanks Oz I was aware of the site but had forgotten it. It is easy to attach a picture. Just click on
Attachments and other options at the bottom of the reply pane.

Wow,awesome.keep it up.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: jack78 on April 13, 2017, 02:03:00 PM
Someone did it!

http://amcomics.blogspot.com.es/ (http://amcomics.blogspot.com.es/)
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: fate man on April 15, 2017, 02:15:37 PM
yeah,i have been to the site.it looks real good.
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: The Australian Panther on April 18, 2017, 08:36:56 AM
If there was an Australian Team (and it was limited to Golden or Early Silver Age) I suggest

Captain Atom - Superman
Blue Ghost - Batman
Dark Stranger - Black Canary
Kazanda - Wonder Woman
Char Chapman - Wildcat
Molo the Mighty - Martian Manhunter
Crimson Comet - Hawkman
Captain Power - Adam Strange      https://www.lambiek.net/artists/p/pitt_stanley.htm


Batman - Several Possibilities inc;-
The Australian Shadow
The Raven (Paul Wheelahan version)    https://www.lambiek.net/artists/w/wheelahan_paul.htm
Catman (John Dixon)                         https://www.lambiek.net/artists/d/dixon_john.htm
Sir Falcon

NarfStar lists

1/ Jetman. The Australian Industry was full of black and white reprints of English and American comics.

I don't know where Jetman comes from but everything about the layout, dialogue and placenames in the story says its an American reprint.

2/ Grey Domino. Thought this was an English Reprint because of its overwhelming Englishness. Apparently its creator, Terry Trowell spent a good period of his life in England. Created in Australia but not characteristically Australian.   https://www.lambiek.net/artists/t/trowell_terry.htm



Australian Comics of this era are very difficult to get hold of, I sold the few I had decades ago. If I ever manage to come across any I will endeavor to post them.           
     
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: jack78 on August 19, 2017, 08:01:11 PM
https://operator-v.deviantart.com/gallery/ (https://operator-v.deviantart.com/gallery/)
Title: Re: Alternate JSA
Post by: narfstar on August 20, 2017, 01:38:19 AM
Some cool and interesting pics there.