[professor echo]

Unfortunately, the comic is very disappointing despite the awesome attraction of the beautiful cover art. The biggest trouble is that there really aren’t any stories per se, they are more like illustrated historical facts and figures with some very perfunctory drama inserted. Plus outside of the first story, where the art is very nicely composed and effective, the rest of the stories look like rank amateurs. Some action scenes aren’t too bad, but faces and bodies are barely rendered at all. Ultimately, the biggest offender is that the book is just boring as hell. I credit Charlton for the variety of concepts and subjects they tackled, but man if they can’t even get stories about wartime submarines to be interesting and exciting, it’s a bad sign.

Link to the book: Submarine Attack 11