THE GANG THAT COULDN’T SHOOT STRAIGHT (1971)
The Movie That Couldn’t Shoot Straight (4 of 10)
In Brooklyn, an Mob underling is given "one more chance" to do right, by organizing an international bike race. He does so BADLY, his boss tells him from now on, he's going to become his chauffeur, if he wants to go on living! Instead, he decides to KILL his boss, so he can take over. But like clockwork, everything he and his gang of idiots plan goes terribly, incompetently wrong.
Meanwhile, a hopeless schmuck who was invited over from Italy for the bike race (that wound up not happening) decides to stay, and becomes romantically involved with the sister of the guy who's trying to kill the boss.
In 1969, newspaper columnist Jimmy Breslin wrote a hilarious novel based on a real-life New York gangster. 2 years later, Robert Chartoff & Irwin Winkler (POINT BLANK, THE MECHANIC, ROCKY and all its sequels) produced a film version. Waldo Salt (MIDNIGHT COWBOY, SERPICO, THE DAY OF THE LOCUST, COMING HOME) did the screenplay, and James Goldstone (a ton of TV shows, including 2 of the earliest episodes of STAR TREK) directed.
What the HELL went wrong?
This film has a pile of known, very-talented actors, yet the story-telling is almost incoherent, and for a comedy, a full 44 minutes went by before I laughed the first time.
In the late 70s, my best friend loaned me the book to read. It was FUNNY! But when I later taped the film off Cinemax, I remember having the impression I was seeing a bad "Reader's Digest" version of the book. As other have said, the jokes fell flat, most of the plot details were missing, and re-watching it again more than 40 years later, it really seems to me, somebody decided to focus on the really lame love story between the biker and the gangster's sister to the almost-total exclusion of the rest of the book. It's almost like they made a 3-hour movie... and then CUT 90 minutes out in the editing room. (Hey-- maybe they did!)
The BEST line in the novel, where the viscious "Mama" tells her boys, "NO MISS!" when they go to work each morning, is nowhere to be found. And although it's been about 45 years since I read the book, I'm pretty sure they changed part of the key scene in the story where they try to bump off the boss in the Italian restaurant. My memory may be playing tricks on me, but I don't think so. I distinctly recall someone running from the restaurant after the hit goes wrong, only to be hit by a moving car by accident. The fact that a similar hit also takes place in THE GODFATHER (also published in 1969, and turned into a movie in 1972), suggests either both novels took inspiration from the same real-life event, or one of the authors swiped from the other. It was MUCH-funnier in the 1998 spoof MAFIA!, written and directed by Jim Abrahams (AIRPLANE!).
Among the cast are Jerry Orbach (20 years before LAW AND ORDER), Leigh Taylor-Young (I LOVE YOU, ALICE B. TOKLAS), Jo Van Fleet (GUNFIGHT AT THE O.K. CORRAL), Lionel Stander (1941), Robert De Niro (I must be the only movie-goer in the whole world who is SICK TO DEATH of this guy, so, of course, the bulk of the film focuses on HIS irritating, unfunny character), Herve Villechaize (THE MAN WITH THE GOLDEN GUN), dubbed by Paul Frees (THE THING FROM ANOTHER WORLD), Joe Stantos (THE ROCKFORD FILES), Frank Campanella (countless TV shows), Harry Basch (3 GET SMARTs and a STAR TREK), Burt Young (ROCKY), Jackie Vernon (most famous as a nightclub comic), and Philip Bruns (250 episodes of MARY HARTMAN, MARY HARTMAN and an Ellen Foley episode of NIGHT COURT). With all this talent in front of the camera, you'd think a film that would be a HELL of a lot better, more cohesive, and a LOT FUNNIER, should have resulted.
Heck, even the so-memorable scene where they decide to drop a dead body off the center of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge barely registers when it happens. And I was describing that in detail over the phone to a close friend just before re-watching the film. I'm pretty sure my description of it was funnier than its actual depiction in the movie.
It's hard to connect that the guy who directed "Where No Man Has Gone Before" and "What Are Little Girls Made Of?" on STAR TREK was involved in this thing. I think I'm gonna get myself a copy of MAFIA! sometime soon. That one I remember being actually funny.