Well, I'm a happy guy now.
Ron Frantz and Mort Todd, the guys who did the Return of Skyman comic, are on facebook right now still claiming to own Skyman. I guess they've been causing a stink with Dynamite and now with Dark Horse for using the character. They still claim they bought the rights from the owner, but I have yet to see any evidence that they do, in fact, own the character. I'm pretty sure you can't own a public domain character. I'm trying to find out, but I'm not having any luck so far.
Ron Frantz, via facebook:
This is Ron Frantz here: I guess it is appropriate that I should address your question instead of Mort. First, let me say that simply because someone (anyone) might claim that certain comic book characters are PD does not make it so. In the case of Skyman and The Face, I base my claim of ownership on the fact that I purchased the rights in 1986 from the creator and original publisher, Mr. Vincent Sullivan. I have addressed this situation several times recently in Ditkomania and elsewhere. As you probably know, I published comics featuring the characters in 1987. I still have the cancelled checks and my original correspondence with Mr. Sullivan. I am represented by legal counsel and I am both willing an able to produce these documents in Federal Court if push should ever come to shove. Now, as to why I have "allowed" other publishers to use the characters in other publications, I have not. This has ordinarily been done without my knowledge or consent. I have most recently brought these matters to the attention of one particular publisher, who has been informed that I am prepared to pursue litigation if necessary. As you put it...I am not "trying to be a dick or anything," but it is simply a matter of necessity to protect my rights and legal ownership of the characters. By my way of thinking, this is only fitting and proper. I hope you (and others) will respect this. As the matter now stands, ACE Comics is the only publisher authorized to use the characters in comic books or any other media.