well i've been interested in these mammoth collections for awhile now and i finally decided to try one out.I can't say i was disapointed because i was expecting mixed quality and that's what i got .The book is about half pre-code crime comics and half modern crime comics.only 2 of the modern stories impressed,TORPEDO drawn by the great Jordi Bernet and Ms.Tree by Max Allen Collins and Terry Beatty.There is some great stuff included -Jack Cole's Murder morphine and me Alex Toth's Crushed Gardenia and stories featuring Will Eisner,Bill Everett,Jack Kirby,Johnny Craig,Bernie Krigstein,and Alex Raymond but i would have been happier if they would have skipped most of the newer stuff.