"And Then There Were None"- WOW! What a cast- Huston, Hayward, and Fitzgerald plus a couple of my very favorite character actors, Mischa Auer and C. Aubrey Smith. First saw it on the late show about 50 years ago. I was a twelve year old boy sitting in the dark and watching this mystery unfold. The surprise ending was a total "gotcha". Cheers, Bowers
The 1st time I saw it (with my Dad, I think), I thought the casting was a bit of a "cheat". The only actors I knew going in turned out to be the HERO and the KILLER! Many years and many movies later, I realized my Dad was right when he said it was an "all-star cast". I've gotten to know almost every person in there from other movies.
My feeling about Agatha Christie whodunits is, there's 2 ways to cast them. Either every actor should be relatively obscure, or every actor should be a big-name star. It's the only way to "play fair"!
Sadly, CBS in the 1980's made a number of TV movies, all updated to the present day, and in every case, the BIGGEST "name" actor turns out to be... well, you get the picture.
My favorite AC film is still
DEATH ON THE NILE. Dad & me went to see that TWICE! (He almost never did that.) I absolutely could not predict where the thing was going the first time, but the way it was done, every single detail was SO clear, I didn't get even the slightest bit lost by the end. And the amazing thing was, the 2nd time, knowing everything in advance, it didn't ruin the film at all! It was SO good-- it just seemed like an entirely different film the 2nd time. I always feel it's very important not to blow the ending of one of these for someone. You only get ONE chance to see it "cold". (My best friend blew the ending of
MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS for me, which may be part of the reason it's never impressed me that much... apart from Albert Finney, of course. My friend said,
"It came out ten years ago-- I assumed you MUST have seen it by now!" Never, never do that...!)
On the other hand, there's
EVIL UNDER THE SUN. I've seen it at least 4 times (maybe more), and each time, I can never keep all the details straight! I guess they wanted something much more complex than
DEATH ON THE NILE, and they found it.