So when a different (if that's what this is) version is uploaded, all the comments from the previous version are consigned to limbo? Is that really the best approach for a site that actively solicits comments?
Link to the book: Cosmo Cat 03
Well, that's not the norm. there are many issues on the site that have two versions - out of respect for the scanners I believe. And with comments attached. So that must be an abberation. Happened by accident or for another specific reason?
It happens too frequently. Because I use a Mac, and for whatever reason, this upload tool doesn't work perfectly with Macs, all of my uploads have something go wrong, often 2 or 3 different things. So, whenever I upload a book that is incomplete, and a regular scanner has a better copy, and eventually uploads it to replace mine, my upload notes, most times, get removed. For ACGs
Merry-G-Round Giant, the replacements uploader DID copy my notes in full, and posted them in the comments below the book on its download page, But for all others of mine which were removed (as they were in worse condition, or had a few pages missing, my notes were deleted with my upload, and not copied and posted as a comment. In some of those cases, it didn't matter, as my notes only explained how my upload was made, and what was missing. But on a couple, I provided information about the writers and artists, and the publisher, which would have been interesting to the readers, regardless of which set of scans was available for reading.
