ELLERY QUEEN: TOO MANY SUSPECTS (1975)
Never Cheat On Your Wife! (10 of 10)
When a fashion designer is murdered in her apartment, the married man she was having an affair with is the obvious suspect. But as the investigation continues, several other people (including his wife, his son, his chauffer and a burglar who’s been robbing apartments in the area) all come under suspicion as well. Stymied by this, New York Police Inspector Richard Queen gets his murder mystery writer son Ellery to help, and at times, begins to regret doing so.
Near the end of the 1974-75 tv season, NBC aired 2 pilots that wound up going to series the following September. One was McCOY with Tony Curtis, aired on an odd night but which became part of the Sunday Mystery Movie rotation. The other was ELLERY QUEEN, actually aired during the Sunday Mystery Movie timeslot, but which instead became a one-hour weekly when it went to series. I’d say both were far-better than AMY PRENTISS, which only had 3 regular movies, but, maddeningly, neither of the new shows lasted more than a single season.
It turns out, by 1975, there had been no less than 9 previous film versions of ELLERY QUEEN! There were a paid of one-off movies in the 1930s, a pair of short-lived movie series in the 1940s, 4 different tv series in the 1950s, and a terribly-misguided unsold tv pilot in 1971. At the time, this 1975 tv movie was my first exposure to the character. As of this writing, I’ve seen all but the 1950s versions, and of the 6 that I have seen, I rate this one as BY FAR the BEST one ever done!
Jim Hutton (THE GREEN BERETS, HELLFIGHTERS) is “Ellery Queen”, young, brilliant, so focused at times as to be downright absent-minded, and according to his Dad, the worst driver in the world. He tends to think ouside the box, like when he sets a trap for the burglar, just to use him to clear one of the murder suspects.
David Wayne (BATMAN) is “Inspector Queen”, alternately warm or agitated, depending on the moment, who wants his son’s help solving complicated crimes, but also finds himself arguing with him so much that at one point he threatens to cut him out of his will. Harry Morgan played the part in 1971, and he was every bit as good as Wayne, in fact, to me, the ONLY good thing about that film.
John Hillerman (BLAZING SADDLES, MAGNUM P.I.) is “Simon Brimmer”, a radio actor who plays a detective, who at first wants to adapt Ellery’s real-life cases and pass them off as his own, but later decides to act as a real-life detective, trying to get to the solution before Ellery can. He was fun in this pilot movie, but when the show went to a series, he became increasingly-annoying, virtually this show’s “Dr. Smith”.
Nancy Kovack (JASON AND THE ARGONAUTS) is “Monica Gray”, the murder victim, who presents Inspector Queen with a baffling clue when she yanks out the electric cord to her TV set just before dying. Ellery eventually decided to find out exactly what was on the screen at the moment she died.
Ray Milland (THE UNINVITED) is “Carson McKell”, who was in the process of ending his affair the very night his mistress was murdered.
Kim Hunter (PLANET OF THE APES) is “Marion McKell”, who figured out her husband was unfaithful, and the night of the murder, went to visit her, just to get a look her “competition”.
Monte Markham (DEATH TAKES A HOLIDAY) is “Tom McKell”, the hot-headed son who objects violently to having his parents accused of murder.
Tim O’Connor (BUCK ROGERS IN THE 25TH CENTURY) is “Ben Waterson”, the family attourney who defends Carson in court.
Gail Strickland (the NIGHT COURT pilot) is “Gail Stevens”, Carson’s secretary, who helps Ellery prove that at least Mrs. McKell couldn’t have done it.
15-year-old Frannie Michel played Ellery’s young cousin “Penny”, who I found quite charming. It’s disappointing she never appeared in the follow-up series.
This movie and the subsequent series was done as a period piece set in 1947, and had more class, more style and more entertainment value than any of the existing NBC Mystery Movies combined! I loved it when I first saw it, and again when I saw it on a rerun. I wasn’t surprised it went to series, but was terribly saddened when it ended after only one year. How this could end so soon while something like COLUMBO just went on and on year after year was beyond me.
As part of my chronological NBC Mystery Movie marathon, I was able to see a crystal-clear print of this on Youtube, and had the most bizarre experience. I’m certain I saw this twice before, but it’s been DECADES—and yet, it felt as if I’d only watched it recently, so many parts of it were so vivid, so clear in my mind. I haven’t had a thing like that happen since I got the DVD set for THE TIME TUNNEL and watched the pilot, “Rendezvous With Yesterday”, for the first time since September 1966!
I haven’t looked to see it this series is available on disc yet, but, if it is, I’m sure I’ll be going after it.