I feel as if I am reviewing a mid-to-late 1950s ACG book.
When The Earth Was YoungThe idea that an advanced extraterrestrial civilisation from a far-off planet, visited Earth millions of years ago, is a good one, albeit oft-used. I can't recall that a dinosaur eating a modern-style, advanced technological man-made instrument, only to be found by modern Earth=bred Human scientists millions of years later ever being used before. I was disappointed that the artist didn't research the structure of a Tyrannosaurus very well, as the well-known head shape was conspicuously inaccurate, and, so, obviously wrong-looking. Otherwise, the artwork wasn't bad. A hand gun that can set off a blast that would produce a many megaton explosion, the equivalent to one of the earliest atomic bombs is a bit hard to believe. Who would ever want to use it, knowing they couldn't propel it far enough away from themselves to not become burnt to a crisp and evaporated almost instantly after its firing? The artwork was adequate in style, but the reproduction of the inks was not good, and there was little shading for gradation of darkness, and less detail than needed for a black and white only printing.
The Gravy TrainThis morally-correct story about a person who gets a bad break at birth that sets the whole tone for his life, and demonstrates that if one does his best to do what is right in life, he or she will be rewarded in the afterlife, was entertaining if not unexpected. It is ironic that his act of doing his good deed gets him killed, which is his ticket to the gravy train of his endless pleasurable, heavenly afterlife he always desired, as well as his ticket for leaving the miserable existence he had in his life on Earth. The artwork on this story was quite good.
Clem Never Does Anything BigThis is a commonly used theme, that a ne'er-do-well rises to the occasion when everything is on the line, either through moral fortitude, selfless dedication to do what is right, a never-give-up attitude, or just plain luck, to do what is really important in life, rather than go by Human society's taught selfish values, to do something important, with a lasting, positive effect. The not-so-bright hero, although basically honest, is driven by his lack of knowledge and country folktales about The US Federal Government's actions ALL being detrimental to them, to accidentally scare off technologically superior extra-terrestrial invaders from invading The Earth. And he never learns what a great act he performed for Humankind. It's a story that's been told many times (including a silly version starring Disney's professor Ludwig Von Drake); but THIS version has a reasonably clever and tight plot, and is an entertaining way of making that result happen. The artwork was fine.
Ina's Intuition - 2 Page Text StoryThis is a typical twist ending driven scenario story which uses a ghost town and old legends to try to develop some suspense. But that fails, as 2 pages of text is much too short to really develop a scary or suspenseful mood, do any character development, or do much more than provide the bare bones of explaining what happened with no details. Of course, given the living in a cursed house near a ghost town setup, the hero doesn't get the quiet place to write his book. But, luckily for him and his wife, their falling prey to the cabin's curse ends with the lucky twist that they find a gold mine (or vein) under the collapsed floor of their cabin. And the newly-rich couple live happily ever after, with his not needing to write the book, or ever work again. Not much of a story. Not very imaginative. More proof that 2 pages of text isn't really long enough to do much more than tell a joke, or write a 2-page story scenario.
The Opal of Ali KharThis is a story of magic and ancient Middle Eastern legend of The Jinn. I am very surprised that this particular legend and Jinn's entrapment was written to only have been a paltry 300 years before. ANY deviation from science's laws of nature is fair game, no matter how unbelievable. Being trapped inside a gemstone, as opposed to a glass bottle is a little different, but not enough to make a significant improvement on the most common version. Use of the convex vs. concave faces of the lens to explain the flinging outward force for releasing, and the pulling/sucking in force for trapping a victim, adds only the slightest (not significant) additional credibility/plausibility to the story's explanation. I was expecting an analogous ending, with a similar result. I think this story, like ALL the others in this genre of ACG comic book, suffers from it's short length, with far too few pages to develop setting, characters, mood, motivation, and have an adequate buildup of suspense. If I were writing such a story, I'd want at the very LEAST, 20 pages, with a full 36-page book's 28-30 pages as what I'd prefer, to do a really good job on it. That would be enough to have room to provide great elaborate detail to the legend, to provide the reader with the feeling of the legend's ancient times (which I'd make at least 4,000 to 5,000 years ago, rather than 300. Those times were much more different from the present, and so, more exotic, and thus, impressive, having long been hidden in the midst of time. We could then also develop the Jinn's character much more, providing at least a sketch of his history tied to the gemstone and his entrapment, and feel his hatred of Mankind leading to why he is so angry and belligerent. This story is way too tame and benign for its basic plot and possibilities. The artwork was adequate.
The Sky BeastHaving been brought up near the edge of The Canadian North Woods, I was intrigued with this story's beginning and potential. It's a typical story about a tall tale teller, who brags and exaggerates a lot, who encounters something legendary and/or unbelievable, and even (for the first time in his life) rustles up here-to-fore untapped courage, and becomes a hero. However, ironically, or based on his karma, there are no witnesses. He has potential proof, but people would think that isn't real proof, but rather something he concocted. I like the idea that he uses the monster's own unique attribute to trick him into trapping himself. It's a little bit unbelievable that sentient extraterrestrials that have the intelligence to develop the technology to travel through a galaxy (at least from one solar system to another), haven't developed anything to control such a beast, and need to depend upon a local being from a civilisation far less developed than theirs, to capture the alien monster. The poor trapper lost his dog. How will he travel by sled to carry supplies. How will he keep up his body temperature on the coldest winter nights? I feel sorry for him.
The artwork was adequate in style, but the reproduction of the inks was not good, and there was little shading for gradation of darkness, and less detail than needed for a black and white only printing.
A Journey To OblivionThis is a very common ghost story, which had no surprises or twists, and because the ending was not different from what direction the plot pointed, it was totally expected, and there was no suspense. It would only be interesting to a reader who was unfamiliar with this genre. More pages would have allowed more room to develop the characters' back stories, to provide fodder for adding suspense and an unexpected twist based on motivation for an unexpected act, with an unexpected thread between characters, and a satisfying story ending. the artwork on this story was quite good. It stands up well in black and white, unlike a few of the others.
The Girl Who Became QueenAnother story involving an extraterrestrial alien society having a visit to Earth. And this is another story about a person who is unsuccessful at his station in life, and who gets a chance to redeem himself, and become worthy. This time, unlike the story of the French-Canadian trapper, it is rather one of the extraterrestrials who is the star. However, this is a fairly boring story, because it follows the path of Cinderella, with no sidesteps, and really, no villain. The idea of a girl and later, young woman, who dreams of becoming a queen, and a king from another planet crossing her path, and both of them ending up with what they want has possibilities for ending up with an excellent story. The large problem of the comet threatening all life on the king's planet adds a great element to the story, leading to lots of suspense. Having the many spaceships of the endangered civilisation go on separate searches for a livable planet and expect to all meet millions or possibly billions of miles away at the first one found, after radio contact, within the same lifetime, sounds impossible. But, that isn't the main problem with the story. Unfortunately, everything points to the expected ending that the Human woman will be everything the alien king was looking for, and will accompany him to wherever he goes, and become his queen. Not only does that happen. But, because of having such a short page count, it happens without any small, or even any tiny roadblocks, along the way. The artwork on this story was adequate.