Once again, DO NOT READ THIS if you haven't seen the film and don't want plot points blown for you.
ON the other hand, if you've watched
MURDER MY SWEET a dozen times already and still can't figure it out, read on...
: )
Henry
PS: There's lot more at the
IMDB site in this one thread,
"Help! I'm confused!!!! Is there a coherent explanation anywhere!" *****
SPOILERS!!!!!*****
"I would love to know what happened!" Me too.
"The key thing that Marlowe eventually discovers is that Ann's stop-mother, Mrs. Helen Grayle, is actually Velma Valento, the woman Moose has been looking for." This is THE key piece of information that they hold back until nearly the end of the movie. The first time I got a sense of it in the film was when Marlowe, out of nowhere, tells Moose he's found Velma. WHA'...
I didn't get that.
Sometimes it's fun, KNOWING a plot (after you've seen it or read it), to watch again, this time knowing in advance, and being able to piece everything together because you've seen it before. But NOT this time. KNOWING in advance who Velma really was, I STILL could not make heads or tails of this plot!!!
"When Marlowe sees Mrs. Florian making that phone call, she is calling Velma (Mrs. Helen Grayle) to let her know that a detective named Philip Marlowe is looking for her." 4 or 5 times I'vbe watched the film, I still didn't "get" that. What kind of screenplay was this, anyway?
"I certainly didn't catch all of that from watching the film." Me either!
"Chandler built his plotline for the novel by combining three short stories he'd previously published in Blask Mask magazine" Just like
THE BIG SLEEP was based on 2 shorter stories. Did this guy have a shortage of story ideas?
""Ann Grayle" -- the stepdaughter -- doesn't exist in the book; "Ann Riordan," on the other hand, is a freelance writer who happens upon the scene after Marriott is murdered and takes an interest because her deceased father was a cop. Establishing this cinematically would have weighed down the continuity, however." I found it ironic that the only version of this story that DID feature "Ann Riordan" was-- heh--
THE FALCON TAKES OVER.
I believe Ann Riordan also appeared in a couple episodes of the Powers Booth TV series, played by Kathryn Leigh Scott (one of my favorites!).
"I lost interest about 1/3 of the way through." I keep hoping it'll make more sense on repeat viewings. Not so far.
"that scene at the Coconut Beach Club was a huge risk for Velma/Mrs. Grayle, if she knew that Moose was going to be there. If Moose had spotted her, that would have blown a few things wide open for her" KNOWING Mrs. Grayle was Velma, that thought was going thru my mind, too. Moose showing up at that exact moment, she had to have gotten Marlowe there just so he'd be a target. I just wasn't sure why until in read this thread. (5 viewings of the film certainly didn't help. I'm not usually dense with mysteries like this...)
"It is possible that Velma/Mrs. Grayle wanted Moose and Amthor to get connected so that Moose might bump off Amthor, or even Amthor could have bumped off Moose? Just a thought... They were both problems to her." A very good point. As it happens, Moose DID kill Amthor. It was funny how when Marlowe blurted that out, he realized he'd made a mistake, since Mrs. Grayle WANTED both Amthor and Marlowe out of the way.
"I remember reading once a really long time ago that Chandler said his plots were so confusing that sometimes even he wasn't sure what was going on with them - especially in the Big Sleep." The irony, for me, is that the 1st time I saw thru
THE BIG SLEEP-- the version with Robert Mitchum-- I had NO TROUBLE WHATSOEVER following every single detail of the plot. (Do you know, there are actually people online who COMPLAIN about that movie's plot being told in such a crystal-clear fashion???)
I'm really glad that amidst all the discussions about which Marlowe is best of which version of this story is best, that there was at least ONE thread actually discussing the "plot" (and I use that word loosely-- heehee).